CHANG Shi-hao,GENG Zhen,YANG Qing-chun,et al.Application of Improved Radar Chart Analysis Method in Soybean Variety Selection and Breeding[J].Soybean Science,2020,39(06):862-868.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2020.06.0862]
改进雷达图分析法在大豆品种选育中的应用
- Title:
- Application of Improved Radar Chart Analysis Method in Soybean Variety Selection and Breeding
- Keywords:
- Soybean; Variety selecting; Radar map; Quantify; Comprehensive assessment
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 为解决传统雷达图在分析过程中存在因评价指标排序不同而引起最终结果不一致以及相邻评价指标相互影响的问题，本研究对传统雷达图分析法进行改进，引入评价指标权重，并根据权重大小首次采用“座次”排序方法对评价指标进行排序，以相邻评价指标的角度平均值作为夹角值，并计算评价对象所对应雷达图的n边形面积和周长，再引入评价函数计算各评价对象的综合评价值进行定量评价。以2018年国家黄淮海夏大豆区域试验南片B组的15个参试品种（系）为例绘制雷达图，周豆33号、兴豆6号和荷豆33号评价指标协调性较好，临豆11、山宁23和中黄202评价指标协调性较差，其它9个评价对象协调性趋于中间。改进雷达图分析法评价结果与仅依靠产量的评价结果基本一致，但稍有不同，排名结果差别最大的为兴豆6号、祥丰2号和临豆11。利用改进的雷达图分析法能够弥补仅对产量单一性状进行评价中存在的不足。
- Abstract:
- In order to solve the problem of inconsistency of final results caused by different order of evaluation indexes and interaction between adjacent evaluation indexes in the analysis process of traditional radar chart, the traditional radar chart analysis method was improved by introducing the weight of evaluation indexes. The ranking method of ‘seat order’ was adopted for the first time to sort the evaluation indexes base on the weight of valuation indexes. The average value of the angles of adjacent evaluation indexes was taken as the included angle value. This study calculated the n-sided area and perimeter of the evaluation object, introduced the evaluation function to calculate the comprehensive evaluation value of each evaluation object and carried out quantitative evaluation. The 15 testing varieties in south group B of Huang-Huai-Hai summer sowing soybean were used as the evaluation object to map radars. The compatibility of evaluation indexes of Zhoudou 33, Xingdou 6 and Hedou 33 were better, the compatibility of Lindou 11, Shanning 23 and Zhonghuang 202 were worse, and the other 9 evaluation objects tend to be in the middle. The evaluation results of the improved radar chart analysis method were basically consistent with that of only relying on the yield, and with a little difference. Xingdou 6, Xiangfeng 2 and Lindou 11 had the biggest difference in ranking results. It is suggested that the improved radar chart analysis method could make up for the deficiency in the evaluation of single character.
参考文献/References:
［1］Zhang H J,Hou Y Y, Zhang J Y, et al. A new method for nondestructive quality evaluation of the resistance spot welding based on the radar chart method and the decision tree classifier［J］. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2015, 78: 841-851.［2］乔鹏程, 吴正国, 李辉.基于改进雷达图法的电能质量综合评估方法［J］.电力自动化设备，2011，31(6): 88-92. (Qiao P C, Wu Z G, Li H. Power quality synthetic evaluation based on improved radar chart［J］. Electric Power Automation Equipment, 2011,31(6): 88-92.)［3］朱唯韦.基于主客观权重的配电系统电能质置综合评估［D］. 合肥: 安徽大学, 2019. (Zhu W W. Power quality evaluation of distribution system based on subjective and objective weights［D］. Hefei: Anhui University, 2019.)［4］程志友, 朱唯韦, 陶青, 等. 基于改进雷达图的配电系统电能质量评估方法［J］.电测与仪表,2019,56(14):34-39. (Cheng Z Y, Zhu W W, Tao Q, et al. Power quality evaluation method of distribution system based on improved radar chart［J］. Electrical Measurement and Instrumentation, 2019,56(14): 34-39.)［5］王梓琪, 肖思曲, 程雨,等. 贵州省医疗保障能力综合评价:基于TOPSIS、聚类、雷达图实证研究［J］. 中国医院,2019,23(12):17-20.(Wang Z Q, Xiao S Q, Cheng Y, et al. The comprehensive evaluation of medical security capability in Guizhou Province: An empirical study based on TOPSIS, clustering and radar chart［J］. Chinese Hospitals,2019,23(12):17-20.)［6］李健, 蔡红丹, 申利未, 等. 基于EGM-雷达图分析法的数字医疗信息服务水平综合评价［J］.医学与社会,2020,33(2): 39-44. (Li J, Cai H D, Shen L W, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of digital medical information service level based on EGM-Radar chart analysis［J］. Medicine and Society, 2020, 33(2): 39-44.)［7］苏顺宝. 基于多维评价模型的长春市某中学教学评价系统的研究［D］.大连: 大连海事大学, 2017. (Su S B. Study on the teaching evaluation system of a middle school in Changchun based on Multi-dimensional evaluation model［D］. Dalian: Dalian Maritime University,2017.)［8］白伟, 孙占祥, 张立祯, 等. 基于雷达图分析的耕层构造效应综合评价［J］.生态学杂, 2020(4):1369-1376. (Bai W, Sun Z X, Zhang L Z, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of plough layer structuring effect based on radar chart method［J］.Chinese Journal of Ecology, 2020(4):1369-1376.)［9］邓禄军, 夏锦慧, 卢扬, 等.雷达图分析法在马铃薯品种特征综合评价中的应用［J］.贵州农业科学,2013,41(7):59-62. (Deng L J, Xia J H, Lu Y, et al. Application of radar chart method in comprehensive evaluation on varietal characteristics of potato［J］. Guizhou Agricultural Science,2013,41(7):59-62.)［10］刘哲, 王虎, 杨建宇, 等.品种筛选多环境测试作图分析方法［J］.农业工程学报,2011,27(10):142-147. (Liu Z, Wang H, Yang J Y, et al. Analytical graphics for multi-environment trials of breed selection［J］. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering,2011,27(10):142-147.)［11］封俊. 基于VBA雷达图的攀枝花烤烟质量综合分析［D］.成都: 四川农业大学,2017. (Feng J. Base on VBA radar chart of flue-cured tobacco quality comprehensive analysis in Panzhihua［D］. Chengdu: Sichuan Agricultural University,2017.)［12］杜薇, 王昌全, 李冰, 等.优化雷达图法在烤烟上部叶外观质量综合评价中的应用［J］.中国烟草科学,2015,36(1): 24-29.(Du W, Wang C Q, Li B, et al. Application of optimized radar-graph method on comprehensive evaluation of appearance quality of upper leaves of flue-cured tobacco［J］. Chinese Tobacco Science,2015,36(1):24-29.)［13］程君奇,曹景林,李亚培,等.基于雷达图的湖北烤烟主要化学成分协调性综合评价［J］.湖北农业科学,2016,55(13): 3387-3389.(Cheng J Q, Cao J L, Li Y P, et al. Comprehensive evaluation on coordination characters of flue-cured tobacco main chemical components base on radar graph［J］. Hubei Agricultural Sciences,2016,55(13):3387-3389.)［14］郑惠莉,刘陈,翟丹妮.基于雷达图的综合评价方法［J］.南京邮电学院学报(自然科学版),2001(2):75-79. (Zheng H L, Liu C, Zhai D N. Comprehensive evaluation method based on radar chart［J］. Journal of Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications(Natural Science Edition), 2001(2):75-79.)［15］王永瑜.雷达图定量综合评价方法中存在的问题及改进措施［J］.统计教育,2007(1): 18-20. (Wang Y Y. Problems and improvement measures in the quantitative comprehensive evaluation method of radar map［J］. Statistical Education, 2007(1): 18-20.)［16］魏春阳,王信民,蔡宪杰,等.基于雷达图的烤烟外观质量综合评价［J］.烟草科技,2008(12):57-60.（Wei C Y, Wang X M, Cai X J, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of appearance quality of fiue-cured tobacco based on radar graph［J］. Tobacco Science and Technology, 2008(12):57-60.）［17］魏春阳,王信民,蔡宪杰,等.基于雷达图的烤烟烟叶主要化学成分协调性综合评价方法［J］.中国烟草学报,2009,15(5):48-53, 57. （Wei C Y, Wang X M, Cai X J, et al. Radar-graph based comprehensive evaluation method on main chemical components and their coordination characters in flue-cured tobacco［J］. Acta Tabacaria Sinica, 2009,15(5):48-53, 57.）［18］李潇潇, 高钰琪, 游海燕, 等.雷达图法的改进及其在军队医院卫勤信息化评价中的应用［J］.解放军医院管理杂志, 2009,16 (1):18-20. (Li X X, Gao Y Q, You H Y, et al. Improvement of radar chart and its application in health service information-based evaluation of military hospitals［J］. Hospital Administration Journal of Chinese People′s Liberation Army, 2009,16(1):18-20.)［19］庄彦, 康重庆, 胡江溢, 等.售电市场质量及其综合评价［J］.电力系统自动化,2009,33(3): 25-29.(Zhuang Y, Kang C Q, Hu J Y, et al. Quality of power sale market and its comprehensive assessment［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2009,33(3):25-29.)［20］李国栋, 李庚银, 杨晓东, 等.基于雷达图法的电能质量综合评估模型［J］.电力系统自动化,2010,34(14):70-74. (Li G D, Li G Y, Yang X D, et al. A comprehensive power quality evaluation model based on radar chart method［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2010,34(14):70-74.)［21］陈勇, 陈潇凯, 李志远, 等. 具有评价结果唯一性特征的雷达图综合评价法［J］.北京理工大学学报,2010,30(12):1409-1412. (Chen Y, Chen X K, Li Z Y, et al. Method of radar chart comprehensive evaluation with uniqueness feature［J］.Transactions of Beijing Institute of Technology,2010,30(12):1409-1412.)
相似文献/References:
[1]刘章雄,李卫东,孙石,等.1983～2010年北京大豆育成品种的亲本地理来源及其遗传贡献[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):1.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.002]
LIU Zhang-xiong,LI Wei-dong,SUN Shi,et al.Geographical Sources of Germplasm and Their Nuclear Contribution to Soybean Cultivars Released during 1983 to 2010 in Beijing[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):1.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.002]
[2]李彩云,余永亮,杨红旗,等.大豆脂质转运蛋白基因GmLTP3的特征分析[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):8.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.003]
LI Cai-yun,YU Yong-liang,YANG Hong-qi,et al.Characteristics of a Lipid-transfer Protein Gene GmLTP3 in Glycine max[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):8.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.003]
[3]王明霞,崔晓霞,薛晨晨,等.大豆耐盐基因GmHAL3a的克隆及RNAi载体的构建[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):12.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.004]
WANG Ming-xia,CUI Xiao-xia,XUE Chen-chen,et al.Cloning of Halotolerance 3 Gene and Construction of Its RNAi Vector in Soybean (Glycine max)[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):12.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.004]
[4]张春宝,李玉秋,彭宝,等.线粒体ISSR与SCAR标记鉴定大豆细胞质雄性不育系与保持系[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):19.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.005]
ZHANG Chun-bao,LI Yu-qiu,PENG Bao,et al.Identification of Soybean Cytoplasmic Male Sterile Line and Maintainer Line with Mitochondrial ISSR and SCAR Markers[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):19.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.005]
[5]卢清瑶,赵琳,李冬梅,等.RAV基因对拟南芥和大豆不定芽再生的影响[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):23.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.006]
LU Qing-yao,ZHAO Lin,LI Dong-mei,et al.Effects of RAV gene on Shoot Regeneration of Arabidopsis and Soybean[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):23.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.006]
[6]杜景红,刘丽君.大豆fad3c基因沉默载体的构建[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):28.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.007]
DU Jing-hong,LIU Li-jun.Construction of fad3c Gene Silencing Vector in Soybean[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):28.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.007]
[7]张力伟,樊颖伦,牛腾飞,等.大豆“冀黄13”突变体筛选及突变体库的建立[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):33.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.008]
ZHANG Li-wei,FAN Ying-lun,NIU Teng-fei?,et al.Screening of Mutants and Construction of Mutant Population for Soybean Cultivar "Jihuang13”[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):33.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.008]
[8]盖江南,张彬彬,吴瑶,等.大豆不定胚悬浮培养基因型筛选及基因枪遗传转化的研究[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):38.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.009]
GAI Jiang-nan,ZHANG Bin-bin,WU Yao,et al.Screening of Soybean Genotypes Suitable for Suspension Culture with Adventitious Embryos and Genetic Transformation by Particle Bombardment[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):38.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.009]
[9]王鹏飞,刘丽君,唐晓飞,等.适于体细胞胚发生的大豆基因型筛选[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):43.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.010]
WANG Peng-fei,LIU Li-jun,TANG Xiao-fei,et al.Screening of Soybean Genotypes Suitable for Somatic Embryogenesis[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):43.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.010]
[10]刘德兴,年海,杨存义,等.耐酸铝大豆品种资源的筛选与鉴定[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):46.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.011]
LIU De-xing,NIAN Hai,YANG Cun-yi,et al.Screening and Identifying Soybean Germplasm Tolerant to Acid Aluminum[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(06):46.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.011]
[11]王亮,黄初女,朱浩哲,等.大豆新品种“延农12”的选育[J].大豆科学,2011,30(05):886.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2011.05.0886]
WANG Liang,HUANG Chu-nv,ZHU Hao-zhe,et al.Selection Report of New Soybean Variety “Yannong 12”[J].Soybean Science,2011,30(06):886.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2011.05.0886]
[12]任海祥,邵广忠,宗春美,等.大豆新品种“牡豆8号”的选育[J].大豆科学,2012,31(05):861.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2012.05.039]
REN Hai-xiang,SHAO Guang-zhong,ZONG Chun-mei,et al.Breeding Report of New Soybean Variety “Mudou 8”[J].Soybean Science,2012,31(06):861.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2012.05.039]
[13]杜成章,李艳花,杨华伟,等.长江春2号大豆新品种选育[J].大豆科学,2012,31(06):1033.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2012.06.039]
DU Cheng-zhang,LI Yan-hua,YANG Hua-wei,et al.Breeding Report of New Soybean Variety Changjiangchun No.2[J].Soybean Science,2012,31(06):1033.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2012.06.039]
[14]栾晓燕,刘鑫磊,马岩松,等.国审高油高产大豆黑农61品种选育[J].大豆科学,2016,35(05):871.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2016.05.0871]
LUAN Xiao-yan,LIU Xin-lei,MA Yan-song,et al.Breeding of Soybean Variety Heinong 61 with High Oil and High Yield[J].Soybean Science,2016,35(06):871.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2016.05.0871]
[15]魏崃.高油、高产、广适应国审大豆品种黑农70的选育[J].大豆科学,2017,36(02):322.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.02.0322]
WEI Lai.Breeding of a High Oil, High Yield and Widely Adaption Soybean Cultivar Heinong 70[J].Soybean Science,2017,36(06):322.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.02.0322]
[16]付亚书,姜成喜,付春旭,等.大豆新品种绥农42的选育与推广[J].大豆科学,2017,36(02):324.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.02.0324]
FU Yashu,JIANG Chengxi,FU Chunxu,et al.Breeding of a High Yield, Disease Resistance and Wide Adaption Soybean Cultivar Suinong 42[J].Soybean Science,2017,36(06):324.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.02.0324]
[17]栾晓燕,刘鑫磊,薛永国,等.国审高产优质大豆新品种黑农83的选育[J].大豆科学,2017,36(06):978.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.06.0978]
LUAN Xiao-yan,LIU Xin-lei,XUE Yong-guo,et al.Breeding of Soybean Variety Heinong 83 with High Yield and Quality[J].Soybean Science,2017,36(06):978.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2017.06.0978]
[18]史晓蕾,刘兵强,闫龙,等.高蛋白大豆新品种冀豆23的选育及栽培技术[J].大豆科学,2019,38(03):497.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2019.03.0497]
SHI Xiao-lei,LIU Bing-qiang,YAN Long,et al.Breeding of High Protein Soybean Cultivar Jidou 23 and Its Cultivation Technique[J].Soybean Science,2019,38(06):497.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2019.03.0497]
[19]李海朝,王金社,练云,等.双国审超高产大豆新品种郑1311的选育与思考[J].大豆科学,2022,41(01):114.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2022.01.0114]
LI Hai-chao,WANG Jin-she,LIAN Yun,et al.Breeding and Thinking of A Super High Yield Soybean Variety Zheng 1311 Approved by National Crop Variety Approval Committee in Two Areas[J].Soybean Science,2022,41(06):114.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2022.01.0114]
[20]刘鑫磊,来永才,栾晓燕,等.国审高油高产大豆新品种黑农87的选育与应用[J].大豆科学,2022,41(02):239.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2022.02.0239]
LIU Xin-lei,LAI Yong-cai,LUAN Xiao-yan,et al.Breeding and Application of Soybean Variety Heinong 87 with High Quality and High Yield[J].Soybean Science,2022,41(06):239.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2022.02.0239]
备注/Memo
收稿日期：2020-04-27