ZHANG Li-qiang,ZHANG Jing- yong,SUN Yu,et al.Meta Analysis of Effects of Molybdenum Fertilizer on Soybean Growth Traits， Yield and Quality[J].Soybean Science,2022,41(03):288-299.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2022.03.0288]
施用钼肥对大豆生长性状、产量和品质影响的Meta分析
- Title:
- Meta Analysis of Effects of Molybdenum Fertilizer on Soybean Growth Traits， Yield and Quality
- Keywords:
- soybean; molybdenum fertilizer; traits; Meta-analysis; influential factor; natural conditions; management measures
- 文献标志码:
- A
- 摘要:
- 为在已有研究进展的基础上整体分析施用钼肥对大豆生长性状、产量和品质的影响，系统量化分析种植地区、气候特征、土壤特性、品种和施肥播种措施等影响因子对大豆产量和品质的影响程度，从而为构建合理钼肥施用策略提供理论依据，本研究收集并整理1971—2021年发表的钼肥施用种植大豆相关文献，以Meta分析方法定量统计，整体分析施用钼肥对大豆生长性状、产量因子和品质性状的影响，系统分析不同区域、自然条件和田间管理措施下施用钼肥对大豆产量和品质的影响。结果表明：本研究共收集到98篇文献，6 612组数据。与不施钼肥相比，施用钼肥可显著增加大豆地上部干重（17.9%）、叶面积指数（15.52%）、茎粗（13.77%）、叶绿素含量（12.06%）、分枝数（8.95%）、主茎节数（1.35%）、根瘤数（26.05%）、根干重（23.37%）、根系活力（19.54%）、侧根数（9.22%）、单株荚数（16.72%）、单株粒数（13.21%）、百粒重（3.83%）、产量（16.99%）和蛋白质含量（7.25%）。华中、华北和西北地区施用钼肥对增加产量、蛋白质和脂肪含量效果最好，分别增加23.62％、10.37％和3.665％。钼肥拌种施用更有益于大豆产量的增加；拌种和叶面喷施同时进行有助于大豆蛋白质和脂肪的积累；施用钼肥配合穴播播种对大豆产量和蛋白质含量增加效果更好。大豆早熟品种配合砂质土，降水量800~1 500 mm、年平均温度>15 ℃、年日照时数1 100~2 200 h条件下更适合大豆增产。大豆晚熟品种配合黏质土土壤施用钼肥后高温、多雨和少日照条件下更有利于提高大豆蛋白质含量。低雨、低温、多日照更有助于大豆脂肪的积累。在我国大豆种植区施用钼肥，尤其是在温度高、日照时数较少和降水量为600~1 500 mm的地区，对于改善大豆的生长性状，提高其产量和品质具有重要意义。
- Abstract:
- In order to clarify the effects of applying molybdenum fertilizer on soybean agronomic traits， yield factors and yield quality， construct a reasonable molybdenum fertilizer application strategy， and provide a theoretical basis for improving soybean yield and quality， we collected and sorted out papers published from 1971 to 2021 to quantitatively analyzed the differences in soybean agronomic traits and yield quality under different management measures， and quantified the climate characteristics by Meta-analysis method. We systematically analyzed the effects of molybdenum fertilizer application on factors such as yield and quality of soybean under different regions， natural conditions and field management measures. The results showed that a total of 98 articles and 6 612 groups of data were collected. Compared with no molybdenum fertilizer， the application of molybdenum fertilizer can significantly increase soybean shoot dry weight(17.9%)， leaf area index(15.52%)， stem diameter(13.77%)， and chlorophyll content(12.06%)， branches number(8.95%)， main stem nodes number(1.35%)， nodules number(26.05%)， root dry weight (23.37%)， root vitality (19.54%)， lateral roots number(9.22%)， pods number per plant(16.72%)， seeds number per plant(13.21%)， 100-seed weight(3.83%)， yield(16.99%) and protein content(7.25%). Application of molybdenum fertilizer in Central China， North China and Northwest China had the best effects on yield， protein and fat content， respectively， which were 23.62%， 10.37% and 3.665% increment. The application of molybdenum fertilizer for seed dressing was more conducive to the increase of soybean yield， and the simultaneous application of seed dressing and foliar spraying can help the accumulation of soybean protein and fat content. Application of molybdenum fertilizer combined with hole sowing had a better effect on increasing soybean yield and protein content. Soybean early-maturing varieties combined with sandy soil， precipitation 800-1 500 mm， annual average temperature>15 ℃， and annual sunshine hours 1 100-2 200 hours were more suitable for increasing soybean production. Late-maturing soybean varieties combined with clay soils after applying molybdenum fertilizer were more conducive to increasing the protein content of soybeans under the conditions of high temperature， more rain and less sunshine. Low rain， low temperature and more sunshine were more conducive to the accumulation of soybean fat content. The application of molybdenum fertilizer in soybean planting areas， especially in areas with high temperature， low sunshine hours and precipitation of 600-1 500 mm in China， is of great significance for improving the agronomic characteristics of soybeans and increasing its yield and quality.
参考文献/References:
［1］姜佰文. 不同水分条件下硼、钼对大豆作用机制的研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 东北农业大学， 2006. (JIANG B W. Study on the mechanism of boron and molybdenum on soybean under different moisture conditions[D]. Harbin: Northeast Agricultural University， 2006.)[2]BANERJEE P， DAS P， SINHAS. Importance of molybdenum for the production of pulse crops in India[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition， 2021(1): 1-11.[3]魏向文， 温永煌， 翁善兰， 等. 江西土壤微量元素含量水平与微肥效应[J].土壤肥料， 1986(1): 23-27， 18. (WEI X W， WEN Y H， WENG S L， et al. Soil trace element content and micro fertilizer effect in Jiangxi[J]. Soil and Fertilizer， 1986(1): 23-27， 18.)[4]MORGAN P B， AINSWORTH E A， LONGS P. How does elevated ozone impact soybean a meta-analysis of photosynthesis， growth and yield[J]. Plant Cell and Environment. 2003， 26(8): 1317-1328.[5]MILANI G L， OLIVEIRA J A， DE MATOSP E， et al. Leafapplication of molybdenum during soybean seed maturation[J]. Ciência e Agrotecnologia， 2010， 34(4): 810-816.[6]GOLO A L， KAPPES C， CARVALHO M A C D， et al. Quality of soybean seeds produced with the application of different doses of molybdenum and cobalt[J]. Revista Brasileira de Sementes， 2009， 31(1): 40-49.[7]MARCONDES J A P， CAIRES E F. Application of molybdenum and cobalt in seeds for soybean cultivation[J]. Bragantia， 2005， 64(4): 687-694.[8]刘鹏， 杨玉爱. 氮、磷、钾配施及其与钼、硼配施对大豆产量的影响[J]. 安徽农业大学学报， 2003(2): 117-122. (LIU P， YANG Y A. The effects of combined application of nitrogen， phosphorus， and potassium and their combined application with molybdenum and boron on soybean yield[J]. Journal of Anhui Agricultural University， 2003(2): 117-122.)[9]范彦英， 赵继文， 刘素霞， 等. 硼、钼微肥配施对大豆产量及品质的影响[J].中国种业，2003(10):44. (FAN Y Y， ZHAO J W， LIU S X， et al. Effects of combined application of boron and molybdenum micro-fertilizers on soybean yield and quality[J]. China Seed Industry， 2003(10): 44.)[10]刘鹏. 大豆钼、硼营养研究进展[J].中国农学通报， 2001(6): 41-44， 118. (LIU P. Research progress on soybean molybdenum and boron nutrition[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin， 2001(6): 41-44， 118.)[11]CARLIM E L， MEERT L， REISB， et al. Fertilization with nickel and molybdenum in soybean: Effect on agronomic characteristics and grain quality[J]. Terra Latinoamericana， 2019， 37(3): 217-222.[12]CARDOSO B M， LAZARINI E， MOREIRA A， et al. Effect of foliar molybdenum application on seed quality of soybean cultivars[J]. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis， 2021， 52(6): 666-672.[13]ERBIL E， UCAK A B， TAS T， et al. Effect of foliar application of iron (Fe) and molybdenum (Mo) on yield， protein and nodulation in soybean under agro climatic conditions of sanliurfa[J]. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin， 2020，29(4A): 3033-3039.[14]LEMES E S， DEUNER C， BORGES CT， et al. Foliar application of nutrients and seed treatment: Effect on the yield and physiological quality of soybeans[J]. Revista de Ciências Agrárias， 2017， 40(1): 205-212.[15]杨光鹏. 钼、硼微量元素在大豆生产上应用效果[J]. 现代化农业， 2017(10): 25-26. (YANG G P. Application effect of molybdenum and boron trace elements in soybean production[J]. Modern Agriculture， 2017(10): 25-26.)[16]GELAIN E， JUNIOR E J R， MERCANTE F M， et al. Biological nitrogen fixation and leaf nutrient concentration on soybean as a function of molybdenum and gypsum levels[J]. Ciência e Agrotecnologia， 2011， 35(2): 259-269.[17]刘鹏， 杨玉爱. 钼、硼对大豆品质的影响[J].中国农业科学， 2003， 36(2): 184-189. (LIU P， YANG Y A. The effect of molybdenum and boron on soybean quality[J]. Chinese Agricultural Sciences， 2003， 36(2): 184-189.)[18]VAN KESSEL C， VENTEREA R， SIX J， et al. Climate， duration and N placement determine N2O emissions in reduced tillage systems: A meta-analysis[J]. Global Change Biology， 2013，19(1): 33-44.[19]GUREVITCH J， HEDGES L V. Statistical issues in ecological Meta-analyses[J]. Ecology， 1999， 80(4): 1142-1149.[20]PHILIBERT A， LOYCE C， MAKOWSKI D. Assessment of the quality of meta-analysis in agronomy[J]. Agriculture， Ecosystems & Environment， 2012，148: 72-78.[21]ROSENBERG M S， ADAMS D C， GUREVITCH J. Meta Win: Statistical Softrwure for Meta-Analysis[M]. Sunderland: Sinauer Associates Inc.， 2000.[22]HEDGES L V， GUREVITCH J， CURTIS P S. The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology[J]. Ecology， 1999， 80(4): 1150-1156.[23]CURTIS P S， WANG X A. Meta-analysis of elevated CO2 effects on woody plant mass， form. and physiology[J]. Oecologia， 1998， 113(3): 299-313.[24]CHEN L Z, YE J Q, WANGE R X, et al. Effect of combined application of boron and molybdenum microelement fertilizer on cowpea yield and quality[J]. Asian Agricultural Research, 2016,8(10): 90-92.[25]LI Y Z， TIAN D， FENG G， et al. Climate change and cover crop effects on water use efficiency of a corn-soybean rotation system[J]. Agricultural Water Management， 2021， 255(C). http://citec.repec.org/rss/eeeagiwatv_255_y_2021_i_c_s0378377421003073.xml. DOI: 10.1016/j.agwat.2021.107042.[26]李殿祥， 永傲强， 刘志军. 温度对大豆生育的影响[J].中国科技信息，2006(22):71， 44. (LI D X， YONG A Q， LIU Z J. The influence of temperature on soybean growth[J]. China Science and Technology Information，2006(22): 71， 44.)[27]顾晓琴.环境条件对大豆品质的影响[J].民营科技， 2012(12):108. (GU X Q. The influence of environmental conditions on soybean quantity[J]. Private Science and Technology， 2012(12): 108.)[28]张贤发，马宏斌.光照对大豆产量的影响分析[J].农村实用科技信息，2007(5): 7. (ZHANG X F， MA H B. Analysis of the influence of light on soybean yield[J]. Rural Practical Science and Technology Information， 2007(5): 7.)[29]胡国华，宁海龙，王寒冬，等.光照强度对大豆产量及品质的影响I，生育期光照强度变化对大豆脂肪和蛋白质含量的影响[J].中国油料作物学报，2004，26(2): 86-88. (HU G H， NING H L， WANG H D， et al. The effect of light intensity on soybean yield and quality I， the effect of light intensity changes during growth period on soybean fat and protein content[J]. Chinese Journal of Oil Crops， 2004，26(2): 86-88.)[30]OLIVEIRA C O E， LAZARINI E， TARSITANO M A A， et al. Cost and profitability of producing molybdenum-enriched soybean seeds[J]. Tropical Agricultural Research， 2015， 45(1): 82-88.[31]段素梅，黄义德，杨安中，等.钼酸铵拌种和喷施对大豆产量、品质和籽粒钼含量的影响[J].大豆科学，2007， 26(2): 181-184，189. (DUAN S M， HUANG Y D， YANG A Z， et al. Effects of ammonium molybdenum dressing and spraying on soybean yield， quality and grain molybdenum content[J]. Soybean Science， 2007， 26(2): 181-184， 189.)[32]刘鹏， 杨玉爱. 钼、硼对大豆光合效率的影响[J].植物营养与肥料学报，2003，9(4): 456-461. (LIU P， YANG Y A. Effects of molybdenum and boron on photosynthetic efficiency of soybean[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizer， 2003， 9(4): 456-461.)[33]付春旭.早熟大豆品种产量与主要农艺性状的灰色关联度分析[J].黑龙江农业科学，2013， 32(9):1-4. (FU C X. Grey correlation analysis between the yield of early maturing soybean varieties and main agronomic traits[J]. Heilongjiang Agricultural Sciences， 2013， 32(9): 1-4.)[34]刘中奇， 李志刚， 谭崴崴. 不同大豆品种籽粒体积、含水量、脂肪和蛋白质积累动态分析[J]. 大豆科学， 2007， 26(2): 194-196. (LIU Z Q， LI Z G， TAN W W. Dynamic analysis of grain volume， water content， fat and protein accumulation of different soybean varieties[J]. Soybean Science， 2007， 26(2): 194-196.)
相似文献/References:
[1]刘章雄,李卫东,孙石,等.1983～2010年北京大豆育成品种的亲本地理来源及其遗传贡献[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):1.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.002]
LIU Zhang-xiong,LI Wei-dong,SUN Shi,et al.Geographical Sources of Germplasm and Their Nuclear Contribution to Soybean Cultivars Released during 1983 to 2010 in Beijing[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):1.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.002]
[2]李彩云,余永亮,杨红旗,等.大豆脂质转运蛋白基因GmLTP3的特征分析[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):8.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.003]
LI Cai-yun,YU Yong-liang,YANG Hong-qi,et al.Characteristics of a Lipid-transfer Protein Gene GmLTP3 in Glycine max[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):8.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.003]
[3]王明霞,崔晓霞,薛晨晨,等.大豆耐盐基因GmHAL3a的克隆及RNAi载体的构建[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):12.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.004]
WANG Ming-xia,CUI Xiao-xia,XUE Chen-chen,et al.Cloning of Halotolerance 3 Gene and Construction of Its RNAi Vector in Soybean (Glycine max)[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):12.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.004]
[4]张春宝,李玉秋,彭宝,等.线粒体ISSR与SCAR标记鉴定大豆细胞质雄性不育系与保持系[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):19.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.005]
ZHANG Chun-bao,LI Yu-qiu,PENG Bao,et al.Identification of Soybean Cytoplasmic Male Sterile Line and Maintainer Line with Mitochondrial ISSR and SCAR Markers[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):19.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.005]
[5]卢清瑶,赵琳,李冬梅,等.RAV基因对拟南芥和大豆不定芽再生的影响[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):23.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.006]
LU Qing-yao,ZHAO Lin,LI Dong-mei,et al.Effects of RAV gene on Shoot Regeneration of Arabidopsis and Soybean[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):23.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.006]
[6]杜景红,刘丽君.大豆fad3c基因沉默载体的构建[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):28.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.007]
DU Jing-hong,LIU Li-jun.Construction of fad3c Gene Silencing Vector in Soybean[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):28.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.007]
[7]张力伟,樊颖伦,牛腾飞,等.大豆“冀黄13”突变体筛选及突变体库的建立[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):33.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.008]
ZHANG Li-wei,FAN Ying-lun,NIU Teng-fei?,et al.Screening of Mutants and Construction of Mutant Population for Soybean Cultivar "Jihuang13”[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):33.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.008]
[8]盖江南,张彬彬,吴瑶,等.大豆不定胚悬浮培养基因型筛选及基因枪遗传转化的研究[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):38.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.009]
GAI Jiang-nan,ZHANG Bin-bin,WU Yao,et al.Screening of Soybean Genotypes Suitable for Suspension Culture with Adventitious Embryos and Genetic Transformation by Particle Bombardment[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):38.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.009]
[9]王鹏飞,刘丽君,唐晓飞,等.适于体细胞胚发生的大豆基因型筛选[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):43.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.010]
WANG Peng-fei,LIU Li-jun,TANG Xiao-fei,et al.Screening of Soybean Genotypes Suitable for Somatic Embryogenesis[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):43.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.010]
[10]刘德兴,年海,杨存义,等.耐酸铝大豆品种资源的筛选与鉴定[J].大豆科学,2013,32(01):46.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.011]
LIU De-xing,NIAN Hai,YANG Cun-yi,et al.Screening and Identifying Soybean Germplasm Tolerant to Acid Aluminum[J].Soybean Science,2013,32(03):46.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-9841.2013.01.011]
[11]陈忠群,闫艳红,杨文钰,等.净套作条件下钼肥拌种对大豆光合特性及产量的影响[J].大豆科学,2015,34(06):982.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2015.06.0982]
CHEN Zhong-qun,YAN Yan-hong,YANG Wen-yu,et al.Influence of Seed Treatment with Molybdenum on Soybean Photosynthesis and Yield under Mono-cropping and Relay Strip Intercropping System[J].Soybean Science,2015,34(03):982.[doi:10.11861/j.issn.1000-9841.2015.06.0982]
备注/Memo
收稿日期：2021-10-20